Insurance - Who did you have good luck with?

I know this has been covered before but there's no search as far as I can tell ...

Farmers gave me a good rate as an 'estimate' - now that I have a VIN its more than doubled! Not happy. Needed to shop them anyway.

What companies have you gotten 'normal car' rates from (preferrably not Bob's Auto Insurance & Stuff)? Thanks!

Red arriving by the end of this month!

GEICO, Progressive


USAA gave me a great price, about $100 less per 6 months than my 11 yr old Honda CRV due to the always on location tracking I assume.

Ace insurance. Under $900.


I happen to have gotten great rates from Bob's Auto Insurance & Stuff. He might seem a little... rural, but that doesn't mean you should discount him ;)

State Farm was fine. Virtually no more expensive than my other (older and cheaper) cars.


GEICO - less than half of what Mercury quoted and 30% less than Farmers.



Often you can do better with regional insurance companies rather than national ones. What state are you in?

State Farm quoted me $100/6mo more than the LEAF, despite being double the cost.

Thanks all. I'm in Texas. Appreciate the feedback.

@dbbtex, I'm also in TX and GEICO wants < $20/mo more than the Infiniti it's about to replace, though it's nearly twice as expensive! Can't complain about that...

Geico here as well. All others (ie State Farm, Allstate, Aaa, etc) were hundreds more.



Liberty Mutual has a discount if you use penfed. Got more coverage (250/500) for the same price of my old Mazda Protege at 100/300. Couldn't believe it.

The search is set up at .

Similar to, State Farm quoted me just a bit over $100/6 mo more than my Leaf. I went with them.

State farm, $10 more a month than my E class.

I'm having a heck of a time getting insurance quotes as the VIN for my P85 does not come up for anyone so, they can not figure out a firm price. Does anyone have advise on what model descriptions that Progressive is using so I can get a firm quote from them? Thanks!

Tell them to check both 2012 and 2013 model year files. It's an artificial distinction with Model S, and their files may be confused.



@sjm, If you can qualify for USAA, when you call them, they can do a search against a car database that they have access to. When they did that with mine, they found my VIN. Recommend that you try USAA, if not, ask others if they have access to a car VIN database and can search it.

I have Amica for Homeowners, Umbrella and auto insurance. Recently got my renewal notice and they are charging me over $2000 for my P85. I took my policies to State Farm and their quote is over $1500 savings. Their quote is $1200 annual for the P85 compared to a little over $2000 from Amica. Wife's suv also less with State Farm as well as Homeowners around $800 less. It is just the two of us and we have a clean record. Carry fairly high coverage (250/500) and $100/500 deducticle. Stacked and full tort. Umbrella is $2m. Looks like I'll definitely be switching to State Farm.

I have AMICA for everything. Increase about $1300 annual for 85, used for leisure (not commuting). I work at home.

1.Anyone using Nationwide Insurance?

2. Anyone shopping for insurance before they get their VIN?

3. Any other pointers such as look for Tesla Model S in both the 2012 and 2013 model year files when talking to the insurance companies?